‘Til dementia do us part: An Essay

Last week some may have read articles about Justice Sandra Day O’Connor’s husband- who is in love with another woman. He has Alzheimer’s Disease and this isn’t a rare occurrence.

Former Justice Sandra Day O’Connor’s husband, suffering from Alzheimer’s disease, has a romance with another woman, and the former justice is thrilled — even visits with the new couple while they hold hands on the porch swing — because it is a relief to see her husband of 55 years so content.


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Dementia comes in many forms and is called many things. Some slowly creep up and other forms of these diseases can eat our memories faster than we devour a good meal. In the end, almost all the dementias kill us. I’ve worked with people with Alzheimer’s and it’s a nasty, cruel and degrading disease. It strips people of their humanity and their very soul. Almost always, they turn into people we don’t know and don’t recognize. And we become the strangers in their world: People with dementia forget who their children are; they forget who their spouses are; they believe they are living in days long past and those days constantly turn backwards.

Living history is fascinating. Talking with people who lived in by gone eras, we learn much about them and US. The journey of going back through time is valuable to most people- reading history books and hearing family tales and all. When you’re alive and slowly being forced back to those times though, it’s not the same. When you steadily step back knowing that you’re forgetting the present, the last thing you’re thinking of is history. People with dementia go back, against their will, kicking and fighting all the way.

There are some antidotes of working with this population that are amusing. This love stuff is ever present with people who have dementia, and it shows up in different ways.

Take Wallace: An old lumber jack, Wallace was a widower who developed Alzheimer’s 10 yrs before he was admitted to the Assisted Living facility I worked at (several yrs ago). He was a down to earth, hard working man whose wife had passed away to cancer 15 yrs before his disease took root. Mary, his wife, was all Wally ever talked about. Her beauty; her food, her driving (or lack of good driving); Wallace’s stage of Alzheimer’s seemed to hover around the days he first met Mary. He was forever “stuck” there and for the most part this was a good thing. Being forever 18 sounds good to me.


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Wallace spent his days dressing for non existent but very real-to-him dates with his lady; he primmed and fussed over his appearance and demeanor. He would spend hours making sure his suspenders were just right and that his belt was tightened up enough. He had a knack for using just the right amount of Old Spice cologne- too much and he would wash up again. He sat on the bench over next to the door waiting for Mary to show up. He always had a bouquet of flowers in hand too- it didn’t matter to him that these were fake plastic flowers that we had bought him. Each time that door to the special unit opened he would stand up in anticipation of her arrival. And every time Wallace realized it wasn’t her, he would sit back down and ring his hands and sigh.

So much of Wally’s current life revolved around this endless waiting: It became very difficult to get him to do much else. Like eat. Or go to the bathroom. Or to bed. Wally had a sweet disposition so we were able to distract him enough to get him to do these things. But everything had to tie into Mary’s arrival.

Wally’s daughter was fine with all this. She knew the implications of Alzheimer’s disease and realized these issues might come up.

On the other end of the spectrum we had Sophia: An elegant fashionable lady, Sophie was DX with Alzheimers a couple years prior to her admission. When she came to us she was still very much aware of who she was and what her life had been. She was slowly losing her memories though, and over time she became more and more forgetful of who her family was. She had three grown sons and a husband. Who all visited her daily. Her husband was a Wall Street millionaire and they owned many houses and drove Mercedes and showered themselves with the riches only people of a higher class can afford. Sophie lived in the “higher functioning” unit- the place where residents could stay as long as they could take care of their own basic needs.


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

The day came when Sophie needed more help to carry out the tasks of daily living: Bathing, dressing and appropriate meal manners were slowly being lost to her. She needed to move to the unit I worked on, where Wally lived. She came over to us full of honor and prestige. She got the private room with the best views; she had the private dining room all to herself. Sophie had changed though: She didn’t want to be a recluse. She asked to participate in the activities and goings on. So it went. She slowly began to invest herself into the daily routines of the unit. And she thrived in this new world. Her husband was appalled with this, but he was a smart man: He could see how happy she was when she was with the others.

Working on these units is no easy job. People with Alzheimer’s disease can be very challenging. And dangerous. Many people do fight. They kick, slap, bite, punch; they throw things at the aides. All in defiance to the care we offer- the care they don’t think they need.

A bath? Why? I just took a bath this morning! They don’t remember the last bath was five days ago.
Lunch? I just ate lunch. I’m not hungry! They forget they refused breakfast too…and last night’s meal. And they’re losing weight.

Nurses and aides must chose the battles they fight. The tasks of the unit take priority over the supervision of small and harmless events that often don’t catch our attention.

One of the events that swept right by us was the growing relationship between Wallace and Sophie. Of all the people in the world we never would have thought these two would match up. But they did. Sophie reminded Wallace of his Mary and she had an uncanny resemblance to her as Wally remembered. At first, they carefully hid their blooming love from Sophie’s less and less present husband and sons. They were like teenagers dating someone their parents didn’t approve of.


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

As Sophie began forgetting more and more of who she WAS, she was developing a new life as the woman she had become. Those of us who work with this horrible disease recognize thats it’s best to celebrate the current and often short lived world of our residents. If they think it’s 1920, then it’s 1920! Why fight to get them back to the future, a future that they cannot ever remember? Living in THEIR world is the best way to give them peace and comfort. It might be 1920 for now; next week it could be 1910…and so on.

It’s very sad to see this happen, but it’s very common. Some victims are fortunate enough to get “stuck” in certain periods of their lives, as Wally was. Others lose it all and go back to being the infants they once were. Sophie was regressing at the usual rate, for lack of other term. She was a star struck teenager, in love with a boy who was just a little older.

In one of the few cultural examples exploring old love — the film “Away From Her,” based on an Alice Munro short story and released in the spring — the starting point is similar to the O’Connors’ story. A man who cannot imagine life without his sparkling wife of some decades watches her slip into Alzheimer’s and then a romance with another patient in a nursing home. In the fictional example, the spousal devotion is such that he arranges for her new boyfriend to return to the nursing home after seeing how crushed she is when the man moves away.

When we realized the romance between Wally and Sophie had reached the stage of them two never wanting to apart, it created some challenges for us. First, Sophie’s family was extremely upset about this. Her sons viewed Wally as a money hungry marriage wrecker; her husband was jealous and totally distraught over his wife’s “infidelity” as it were…her family had no real idea of how Alzheimer’s disease destroys the mind- how it robs people of their identity and soul, never mind their memory. They didn’t understand how victims do indeed travel back through the times of their own lives, to decades and years and moments of the their own pasts. Sophie was at a time in her life where she had not met her future husband. She hadn’t recognized him in several months. We educated them and they grew to accept peace with Sophie’s new “life”. Her husband saw Wally as a past version of himself, which is exactly how Sophie viewed Wally.


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Of course, it illuminated the relationships that often develop among Alzheimer’s patients — new attachments, some call them — and how the desire for intimacy persists even when dementia steals so much else.

Sex and old people are often the cited as a reason so many don’t want to grow old. After all, old people can’t really have sex, right?

WRONG. I have seen so many elderly people have sex it’s really mind boggling. Working in a nursing home, a hospice, and the assisted living home I can tell you this: Old people have sex, often, they have wild passionate sex, without any cares as to who is watching. Even with the mind being destroyed, the desire and need for sex is always present. Right up to the end.

Wally and Sophie glowed when they were together. They ate their meals together; they attended activities together; they went to religious services together; they held hands as they walked about the unit together, marveling at the wall colors and artworks and antics of the other residents. They enjoyed each other’s company immensely. They were “allowed” private time together each evening, after much ethical and moral debate, and state Ombudsman assisted guidance.

Sophie tucked Wally into his bed every night before she went to her own room to go to her bed. They always kissed one another good night as though it were their last kiss. One night is was.


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Sophie became ill. She caught the usual round of stomach viruses that attack long term facilities each year. She was really sick though, we could tell something wasn’t right. She was feverish and refused all drinks and care from us. I sat down on the edge of her bed and held her hand- and asked her what was going on. She told me she missed her Wally. They hadn’t been able to be together for almost a week and she told me her heart was breaking. She also did what many people in her condition do: She told me she would die if she didn’t see him soon. I pleaded with management to allow a one time disregard for the isolation rules- to allow Wally and Sophie a visit. Of course they would not bend this stupid rule, even though Wally himself was sick with the same damn bug.

What’s an aide supposed to do? Break the rules, thats what. And I did just that. I signed up to work an overnight shift that week. After I came in and did first rounds, I managed to get Wally into a wheelchair and pushed him into Sophie’s room. Wally had become so weak he could not walk anymore…once in her room, she felt his presence and immediately sat up in her bed, something she had not done in several days. They embraced and kissed one another and talked softly. I did not listen as it was none of my business. I left them alone for about 5 minutes and returned Wally to his bed. As I did rounds the rest of the shift both Sophie and Wally appeared as well as they had been: Sickly but not acutely so.

I left work at 6am and when I came back that afternoon to work 2-10, I heard: Sophie had passed away shortly before breakfast. The nurse on duty noted that she had a smile on her face when she was found. She died a quiet and apparently peaceful death.

I went to see Wally. His daughter had told him. His memory interrupted his ability to absorb this too…When clear he was at peace with it. He fondly reflected upon all the times they shared together- well, not real times but dementia times. He told me about the cruise they went on; their wedding and how she had planned it to happen on her own parents’ anniversary (Wally’s real wedding to Mary did indeed happen on her parents wedding date); he told me all about the birth of their daughter, which is forever mad that he wasn’t able to be present for- he was in the South Pacific at war with Japan…he also mentioned, through all his dementia related confusion, how he saw Sophie just last night and he regaled their last kiss. It left me with tears in my eyes and a large ball in my throat. Then Wally would forget what we were talking about and ask me why I was crying.

The next morning I heard that Wally had passed away- exactly 24 hours to the minute after Sophie. The nurses notes mentioned the smile on his face at time of death. And the peaceful nature of his passing.

The lovers of the unit had died, and so did a part of every one of us who worked there. It was an odd situation for us, and one of the first where we had to get through our own misgivings and prejudices and demons and devils of how to best deal with relationships between residents. It wasn’t uncommon for this to happen- residents falling in love. What was common was the separation of them, by units or a move to another facility. At all costs, the bonding was something we would never allow. It wasn’t appropriate. It was immoral. It was wrong.


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

But was it? Now it’s much more common to see nursing facilities allow these relationships to blossom and bloom. Human rights, a better understanding of the disease process of dementia and the more modern thinking of families has led to this change in thinking.

I felt a sense of bittersweet pride when I read about Justice O’Connor’s husband, and how Sandra dealt with it. Her attitude is to be commended. Not too many spouses fully understand and appreciate what these romances are really about: Times gone by and the world as it IS, to the person with the dementia. They have lost just about everything that made them who they WERE; why not let them enjoy who they are now?

Back Home

Trackback URL for this post:
http://just-raven.com/til-dementia-do-us-part-an-essay/trackback/

  1. Joe Said,

    Wow.

    My first thoughts would be: IS it rape? To allow a man to have relations with your Mother or other loved one, who has dementia? Would she be alright with this in her right mind? Isn’t that the standard to go by?

    My second thoughts are: What a sweet story with a semi sad ending.

    My third thought is: How do religious values play into this?

    November 18th, 2007 | #

  2. Joe Said,

    When we consider that a person with dementia cannot sign their own releases and other important papers, cannot make medical choices and decisions, how can we allow this to happen?

    How long does this sort of “love” last, considering the memory problems?

    A very thought provoking article Raven.

    November 18th, 2007 | #

  3. Raven Said,

    Nope it’s not rape, of course not! We went to the state to seek assistance with all this.

    It’s about allowing people with dementia to live in the world they currently reside in; it’s about honoring the very few choices they can make. It’s about personal freedoms vs. being controlled by others who **think** they know best, Joe.

    We had to get family permissions to allow relationships- beyond the dining together and similar things. It wasn’t easy to do either…we didn’t go out to get permission actually; it came to us from Sophie’s husband, who like Mrs. O’Connor, saw the value in his wife’s new life. Value for her, not him. The woman he loved and married died long ago and what was left then wasn’t HER.

    It’s about not being selfish.

    As for the religious stuff, they did talk about it and it was not endorsed at all. So that input was no longer sought; it was DOA.

    These relationships don’t usually end up sexual. From my experience they last about 2 to 3 mos before one begins to forget the other and move…backwards even further.

    November 18th, 2007 | #

  4. darthcrUSAderworldtour2007 Said,

    Raven, I guess impeached Bubba Clinton had Alzheimers too from 1993-2000!

    November 19th, 2007 | #

  5. Kat Said,

    Well, strictly speaking, it *IS* adultery - the vows do say “in sickness and in health, ’til death do us part.” And it is never good to minimize or trivialize sin…

    … But somehow, I cannot find it in my heart to condemn this. For two people to be able to find a little happiness and comfort in the midst of such a tragic and debilitating disease, well… I think I’d have to make sure that this was really what they wanted, and that the memory of the real spouse/family was gone, and then I think I’d simply do what Raven did.

    I rather think it’s similar to my understanding of how God treats people who are severely mentally handicapped, for instance, or little children who die: God holds us accountable fairly. If something is simply out of the scope of understanding for a person, it’s my understanding that God doesn’t hold that sin against them. Small kids, the mentally handicapped, and people like your Alzheimers patients simply cannot comprehend the nature of their sin; they lack the ability. Therefore, I think that God would not hold this against them. Now, that is my opinion; God, in fact, may say differently, in which case *I* am wrong, and He is right.

    November 19th, 2007 | #

  6. Raven Said,

    Kat I suspect you are correct on this. Not being the religious person, I hate to ponder it.

    Think of it like this:
    These people, in THEIR world, do not believe they are married. Or were married…they’re living in their pasts, in days prior to their weddings. Many seem to get “stuck” here.

    Another period of life so many get “stuck” in is motherhood to young school aged kids. And fatherhood to the same group. Hence we see much wandering with people with dementia, they are often looking for their young kids who haven’t come home from school yet. Moms get worried and panic and Dads get sad. It’s amazing to watch this happen, and fascinating and sad all at once.

    November 19th, 2007 | #

  7. Curtis Said,

    God bless you Raven and thanks for helping out the innocents on their journey through the last phase of life. All watch in awe and delight as they work their way through the birth, toddler, child, not so much their teen years and finally with pride as they reach successful adulthood. It is almost unbearable to witness the finale in these cases.

    regards,
    Curtis

    November 20th, 2007 | #

  8. Always On Watch Said,

    My mother-in-law, widowed many, many years ago, has had Alzheimer’s for several years. Her condition has deteriorated significantly the past two years. She has reached the point that she now longer recognizes her own children, although, for some inexplicable reason, she does occasionally recognize me.

    Before the onset, she had a boyfriend, and he has stuck by her. Now she perceives him sometimes to be my husband’s father. But no matter her perception as to who’s who, this boyfriend brings her tranquillity. We can’t find it in our hearts to object.

    Raven, IMO you did the right and compassionate thing in allowing Wally and Sophie to be together. I further believe that God understands and approves. After all, he knows the demented mind and understands it better than we ever will.

    November 20th, 2007 | #

  9. darthcrUSAderworldtour2007 Said,

    My buddy has Alzheimers and he say’s the good thing about it is that he makes a lot of new friends every day! He also gets to hide the Easter Eggs, and buy and wrap his own Christmas presents.
    Great article Raven. Happy Thanksgiving too!

    November 20th, 2007 | #

  10. Joe Said,

    I still have a big problem with all this. I do. When these people were of sound mind and body would they have done these things? I think not, especially Sophia from the way you describe her life.
    I always thought the standard was to go by what they would do in the right mind. I realize times have changed but this seems a bit over some top.

    Just my opinion though. I don’t have Alzheimer’s Disease, that I know of. I don’t know anyone who does either so I have no experience with the stages and problems and care of these people.

    November 20th, 2007 | #

  11. Joe Said,

    I think my main point is this:
    Where is the dignity for these demented people? Since they have dementia can’t they be distracted into other more appropriate thoughts and activities?

    November 20th, 2007 | #

  12. Raven Said,

    Joe, in the old days of say three or four years ago that was THE standard. And we had so many behaviors and anger and miserable residents; we had depressed residents; we had violent residents.
    For what? To make it all look good? To make US happy to know WE were in control of another persons life- even when that life was changing rapidly due to a nasty disease process no one had any control over.

    When we allow those with dementia to live in THEIR world, the behaviors and moods and misery stop. Shouldn’t that be the standard? To be happy and content, albeit confused happiness and contentment? After all, they are going to die. Sooner than later and usually much sooner than the rest of us. The fighting and kicking need not be. Like I said it’s rare that these relationships go sexual; more often it’s just simple companionship- like hand holding and walking together. Innocent and sweet and totally harmless. Sexual relations are also harmless my friend…

    Where’s the dignity with allowing and enabling demented people to live miserable and fearful and lonely lives? Is it dignified that their families even place them into facilities where they will meet others? I say not and that’s my opinion. If people ask me I tell them: NO nursing homes or assisted living centers- we risk this stuff happening.

    Do you remember what it was like to be in first love? Were you able to think about anything else?

    Same with people who have dementia. They forget, but remember things in THEIR world, including new loves.

    November 21st, 2007 | #

  13. Raven Said,

    AOW thanks for the thoughtful comment. I tend to agree with you and Kat on this. And I would break the rules all over again if faced with the same situation. I have to look at the big picture and have some empathy. Otherwise I have no business being in the care giving field.

    November 21st, 2007 | #

  14. Joe Said,

    Yes it may appear to be innocent and sweet, but I for one do not think I could sit back and watch my wife, demented or not, have relations with another, demented or not, man. As I said in the previous comment, I don’t have the benefit of experience with Alzheimer’s disease in my family so I cannot speak with authority on this.

    It just doesn’t seem right. I would move my wife out of the facility if this were happening. Actually you’re correct in saying when we place loved ones into these places we risk this happening. I won’t do that.

    November 21st, 2007 | #